Key West Haunted History: Ghost Stories, Legends & Paranormal Lore

Best-Selling Author Kitty Newbold

Published by Blue Goat Publishing for Kitty Newbold | Last updated: 2025-05-05

Key West is known for more than just sunshine and cocktails—its haunted history is filled with ghostly legends, chilling tales, and supernatural encounters that have fascinated locals and visitors for generations. In this post, we'll explore the eerie stories and historical hauntings that make this island a paranormal paradise.

💡 Did You Know? Key West is home to one of the most haunted dolls in America—Robert the Doll, who is said to curse visitors who take his photo without permission.

The Spirits of Old Key West

From Civil War soldiers to shipwreck survivors, the spirits said to roam Key West reflect its colorful and tumultuous history. Visitors have reported strange noises, cold drafts, and ghostly figures in historic homes and hotels—many of which date back to the 1800s. These legends have become a treasured part of local folklore, adding a layer of mystery to the island's warm hospitality.

Robert the Doll and Other Local Legends

One of Key West's most infamous paranormal figures is Robert the Doll, a creepy childhood toy believed to be cursed. Housed at the Fort East Martello Museum, Robert is said to move on his own, cause electronic malfunctions, and bring misfortune to those who disrespect him. But Robert is just one of many spooky legends that haunt the island—each tale more spine-tingling than the last.

Haunted Hotspots You Can Visit

For those eager to explore haunted Key West for themselves, there are several must-see stops. The Hemingway House, the Audubon House, and the Key West Lighthouse are just a few historic locations rumored to be visited by spirits. Guided ghost tours offer an entertaining and chilling way to experience these haunted landmarks firsthand.

Book cover of Secrets and Shadows From Old Key West, a paranormal cozy mystery set in Key West

The mysterious Monroe Manor inspired by Key West's haunted history

More Haunted Places in Key West

Marrero's Guest Mansion: Built in 1890 by Francisco Marrero, this Victorian home is now a bed and breakfast—and reportedly still watched over by his late wife. Guests often report cold drafts and glimpses of a ghostly woman in white wandering the halls.
Curry Mansion Inn: Once the residence of Florida's first millionaire, the Curry Mansion is said to be visited by the spirit of Aunt Sally, the legendary inventor of Key lime pie. Her presence is most often felt near the kitchen.
Captain Tony's Saloon: Formerly the city morgue, this popular bar is said to be haunted by multiple spirits, including the "Lady in Blue" who appears in the ladies' restroom.

Inspired by Key West's Haunted Past

If you love exploring haunted history and ghost stories set in sun-soaked places, then Secrets and Shadows From Old Key West is the perfect read for you. This paranormal cozy mystery by Kitty Newbold transports readers to Monroe Manor—a charming bed and breakfast in Old Key West with a chilling past and secrets waiting to be uncovered. As new owner Eliza sets out to renovate the aging inn, she encounters more than creaky floorboards and dusty antiques. Ghostly whispers, cold spots, and the lingering presence of a phantom sea captain pull her into a mystery that blends history, heartbreak, and the supernatural. With the help of her feline companion Tabitha and a few quirky locals, Eliza begins to unravel the manor's past—and her own future. Blending Key West's colorful folklore with a fresh twist on cozy mystery storytelling, this book is perfect for fans of ghost tours, haunted mansions, and stories with heart. Whether you're a local, a frequent visitor, or someone who just loves a good ghost story, this book delivers the perfect blend of warmth and the wonderfully weird.

Buy Now on Amazon

More Key West Paranormal Explorations

Haunted Key West Resources

Explore Key West's Haunted History

Take a virtual tour of Key West's most haunted locations

FAQs

What are some famous haunted places in Key West?

Key West has several famous haunted locations including the Artist House (Robert the Doll), Marrero's Guest Mansion, Curry Mansion Inn, Captain Tony's Saloon (former morgue), Fort East Martello Museum, and the Hemingway House.

Who is Robert the Doll?

Robert the Doll is Key West's most infamous haunted object—a century-old doll once owned by artist Robert Eugene Otto. Visitors report the doll changes positions, causes electronic malfunctions, and brings misfortune to those who mock or photograph him without permission.

Are there ghost tours in Key West?

Yes, Key West offers several popular ghost tours including walking tours through Old Town, haunted pub crawls, and specialized tours of specific haunted locations. These tours combine history, local legends, and paranormal investigations.

What is the most haunted building in Key West?

Many consider Captain Tony's Saloon (formerly Sloppy Joe's) to be the most haunted building in Key West. The building once served as the city morgue and still contains the graves of several bodies discovered during renovations. Patrons report ghostly encounters and unexplained phenomena.